Insights > Valuation Operations
When AI Compresses Execution Time, What Happens to the Billable Hour?
Most valuation firms have built their businesses around a fairly straightforward economic model.
We estimate the time required to complete an engagement, assign professionals with the appropriate experience, and price the work based, at least in part, on the hours we expect to spend.
It’s a model that has worked for decades.
But I think we’re approaching a point where we need to start questioning some of the assumptions behind it.
What happens when work that previously required 20 hours can potentially be completed in two?
And what happens when that reduction in time isn’t the result of cutting corners or simplifying the analysis, but of technology performing increasingly sophisticated portions of the work?
I’ve been thinking about this quite a bit recently, particularly as I’ve been testing newer AI models against actual valuation processes.
The implications go well beyond productivity.
I think we’re looking at a potential change in the underlying economics of the valuation profession.
The Economics of Execution Are Changing
One of the things that has surprised me about recent advances in AI is how quickly the technology has progressed from performing relatively simple tasks to producing sophisticated analytical work.
I’m not talking about drafting emails or summarizing documents.
I’m talking about building financial models, constructing spreadsheets with multiple layers of calculations, and performing work that would ordinarily require significant analyst time.
In one recent test, I asked an AI model to construct a complex valuation spreadsheet incorporating contributory asset charges, required rates of return, and interdependent calculations.
It produced a structurally sound model in minutes.
Now, that doesn’t mean the model was ready to be used without review. It wasn’t.
There were still assumptions to evaluate, formulas to verify, and professional conclusions to consider.
But the time required for the initial technical execution had changed dramatically.
And that’s what I think valuation firm leaders need to pay attention to.
For years, we’ve used technology to make individual tasks more efficient. Better spreadsheets, financial databases, document management systems, and valuation software have all improved productivity.
But much of that technology still required professionals to perform the underlying analytical work.
AI is beginning to change that relationship.
Increasingly, we’re seeing systems that can perform portions of the execution itself.
If that capability continues to improve, the amount of professional time required to complete an engagement could change substantially.
And when execution time changes, the economics of the business change with it.
The Billable-Hour Dilemma
Consider a valuation engagement that historically requires 40 hours of professional time.
A firm might spend those hours collecting information, analyzing financial statements, preparing adjustments, building models, drafting the report, and completing the review process.
Now suppose AI reduces the time required for several of those activities.
The engagement still requires professional oversight. The assumptions still need to be evaluated. The conclusion still needs to be defensible.
But perhaps the work can now be completed in 15 hours instead of 40.
What happens to the fee?
If the firm bills primarily by the hour, greater efficiency could translate directly into fewer billable hours.
That’s an interesting problem.
We’ve spent years investing in technology to improve productivity. But if our revenue is closely tied to the time spent performing the work, there’s a point where productivity improvements can begin working against the traditional revenue model.
Of course, the firm could use the additional capacity to complete more engagements.
And that’s certainly one possible outcome.
But it assumes there’s enough additional demand to absorb that capacity. It also assumes that competitors won’t use the same technology to reduce their prices.
Neither assumption is guaranteed.
Alternatively, firms could maintain their existing fees while delivering the work more efficiently.
That may work in certain situations, particularly where clients are purchasing specialized expertise or a defensible conclusion rather than a specific number of hours.
But as AI capabilities become more widely available, clients may begin questioning why certain engagements cost what they do.
I don’t think there’s one simple answer.
Different types of valuation work will likely support different pricing approaches.
But I do think firms need to start examining the relationship between execution time, pricing, and the value they’re providing.
Because that relationship may look very different in a few years.
Efficiency Alone Isn’t a Business Strategy
There’s a tendency in conversations about AI to focus on how much faster we can perform existing tasks.
And that’s understandable.
If we can complete financial analysis faster, prepare reports more efficiently, and reduce the time spent on repetitive work, those are meaningful improvements.
But I think there’s a limitation to looking at AI primarily through the lens of productivity.
Making an existing process faster doesn’t necessarily mean you’ve developed a better operating model.
For example, suppose a firm introduces AI tools that allow analysts to complete their work in half the time.
That’s a significant productivity gain.
But what happens next?
Does the firm reduce its fees? Increase the number of engagements it accepts? Change its staffing structure? Reallocate professional time toward more complex analysis and review?
Or does it simply continue operating the same way, with fewer hours required to produce each report?
Those are business decisions, not technology decisions.
And I think that’s where the more important conversation needs to take place.
We have to look beyond individual tasks and consider how the entire engagement process should operate when these new capabilities are available.
Some steps may become faster. Others may need to be redesigned. Certain activities may become unnecessary, while new review and validation procedures become more important.
The opportunity isn’t simply to perform the same work more quickly.
It’s to reconsider how the work should be organized, delivered, and priced.
Competitive Pressure Won’t Be Equal Across Firms
There’s another aspect of this that I think deserves attention.
The impact of AI on valuation firm economics won’t necessarily be the same for everyone.
Large firms have some obvious advantages.
They have established client relationships, recognizable brands, substantial resources, and the ability to invest in technology across multiple practice areas.
Once they integrate AI into their valuation operations at scale, they could potentially combine significantly lower execution costs with the market position they already have.
That could create considerable competitive pressure.
But smaller firms have advantages of their own.
They can often make decisions more quickly. They may have fewer internal systems to coordinate, fewer layers of approval, and more flexibility to change established processes.
And right now, I think that flexibility matters.
A smaller valuation firm that understands its workflows and is willing to rethink how work gets performed may be able to adopt new capabilities faster than a much larger organization.
That creates an opportunity.
But I wouldn’t assume that opportunity will remain indefinitely.
As larger firms move from experimentation to operational implementation, their existing advantages could become even more significant.
This is one reason I think firm leaders need to be actively evaluating these technologies themselves.
Not necessarily because they need to become AI developers or technical experts.
But because decisions about technology are increasingly becoming decisions about the future economics and competitive position of their firms.
Those decisions are too important to treat simply as an IT initiative.
What Are Clients Actually Paying For?
Ultimately, I think this brings us back to a more fundamental question.
What is the client buying when they engage a valuation professional?
Is it the time required to build a model, prepare an analysis, and write a report?
Or is it the expertise, independence, credibility, and accountability behind the conclusion?
Historically, those things have been closely connected because performing the technical work required substantial professional time.
But as technology changes the amount of time required, that connection may become less direct.
A client doesn’t necessarily receive less value because a qualified professional can produce a defensible valuation in less time.
In fact, the client may receive greater value through faster delivery, more consistent analysis, or the ability to evaluate additional scenarios.
But the firm still needs to determine how to price that value.
And I think that will require some careful consideration.
For certain engagements, fixed-fee arrangements may become more attractive.
Other engagements may continue to require time-based pricing because the scope, complexity, or uncertainty makes it difficult to establish a predictable fee.
Some firms may develop entirely different approaches based on the type of work they perform and the clients they serve.
I’m not suggesting that the billable hour disappears.
I am suggesting that the amount of time required to execute an engagement may become a less reliable measure of the value being delivered.
That’s a meaningful distinction.
A Strategic Question for Valuation Firm Leaders
I don’t think valuation firms need to abandon their existing business models tomorrow.
And I certainly don’t think every AI capability being demonstrated today is ready for unrestricted use in professional valuation work.
Reliability, confidentiality, quality control, and professional accountability remain essential.
But I also don’t think firms can afford to assume that the economics of valuation engagements will remain largely unchanged.
The capabilities are advancing too quickly for that.
For firm leaders, I think there are several questions worth examining.
How much of our current engagement time is devoted to technical execution versus analysis, review, and professional decision-making?
Which parts of that work could realistically be performed differently with emerging technology?
How would our pricing model respond if execution time declined substantially?
And perhaps most importantly, what would our firm look like if we designed its operating model around the capabilities that are becoming available, rather than the limitations we’ve historically worked within?
These aren’t questions that can be answered simply by purchasing an AI tool.
They require a broader examination of how the business operates.
For decades, the amount of professional time required to perform valuation work has been a central component of how we’ve staffed, managed, and priced our services.
If technology fundamentally changes that amount of time, it seems reasonable to question whether the business model built around it needs to change as well.
I think that’s the conversation valuation firms should be having now.
Better valuation operations begin with better questions.
Explore how ValueVision is building specialized agents, connected operating infrastructure, and practical advisory services for the future of valuation.