Insights > Valuation Operations

Silhouetted team meeting in boardroom at sunset.

Can Smaller Valuation Firms Gain an Advantage in the AI Transition?

For years, larger valuation firms have had some fairly significant competitive advantages.

They have established brands, extensive client relationships, access to resources, and the ability to invest in technology and infrastructure that smaller firms may struggle to justify.

Those advantages aren’t going away.

But I think recent developments in AI are creating an interesting opportunity for smaller and mid-sized valuation firms.

And it’s an opportunity that may not remain open indefinitely.

Historically, building a larger valuation practice required adding people. More engagements meant more analysts, more managers, more reviewers, and more administrative support.

Technology improved productivity, but there was still a fairly direct relationship between the volume of work a firm could perform and the number of professionals it employed.

AI is beginning to change that relationship.

We’re now seeing capabilities that could allow relatively small teams to perform work that previously required significantly greater resources.

That has implications for how valuation firms compete.

And I think smaller firms may have an advantage that hasn’t received enough attention.

Scale Has Traditionally Required People

If you look at the traditional valuation firm operating model, growth has generally been tied to professional capacity.

A firm wins more engagements, hires more analysts, adds experienced reviewers, and expands its ability to deliver work.

There are efficiencies that come with scale, of course. Larger firms can develop specialized teams, standardize processes, invest in research resources, and spread technology costs across a broader client base.

But much of the underlying work has remained labor-intensive.

Financial information needs to be collected and organized. Models need to be constructed. Assumptions need to be researched and evaluated. Reports need to be drafted, reviewed, and finalized.

And every additional engagement consumes professional time.

That has historically placed practical limits on how much work a smaller firm can perform.

A boutique valuation firm may have highly experienced professionals and strong client relationships, but it can’t necessarily compete with a much larger organization on capacity.

At least, that has been the traditional assumption.

I’m beginning to question how much longer that assumption will hold.

What Happens When Systems Provide the Scale?

I’ve spent considerable time recently testing advanced AI models against actual valuation work.

What has surprised me isn’t simply the speed at which these systems can perform certain tasks. It’s the increasing complexity of the work they’re capable of performing.

In one recent test, I asked an AI model to construct a sophisticated valuation spreadsheet incorporating contributory asset charges, required rates of return, and multiple layers of interdependent calculations.

It generated a structurally sound model in minutes.

Now, that doesn’t mean the analysis was complete or ready to be delivered to a client.

The model still required verification, the assumptions needed to be evaluated, and professional review remained essential.

But the initial technical execution was substantially faster than what we would ordinarily expect.

And that changes how I think about professional capacity.

Consider a valuation team with a handful of experienced professionals, access to quality financial data, well-documented processes, and AI systems capable of handling significant portions of the technical execution.

That team may be able to complete considerably more work without adding staff in the traditional way.

It may also be able to deliver work more consistently, reduce the time spent on repetitive tasks, and devote more professional attention to analysis and review.

I’m not suggesting that a five-person firm can automatically perform the work of a fifty-person firm.

The technology isn’t that predictable, and valuation engagements vary considerably in complexity.

But I do think we’re moving toward a point where the capacity of a firm may be determined less by the number of people it employs and more by the quality of the systems and processes supporting those people.

That’s a significant change in the economics of professional services.

Smaller Firms May Have an Advantage in Implementation Speed

There’s another aspect of this that I find particularly interesting.

Large organizations generally have more resources to invest in technology.

But they also tend to have more complicated implementation processes.

There are existing systems to consider, internal approval procedures, information security requirements, governance responsibilities, budget cycles, and organizational structures that have developed over many years.

Those things exist for good reasons.

A large valuation practice can’t simply introduce a new system into its production environment without considering how it affects clients, professional standards, confidentiality, and quality control.

But those requirements can make significant operational changes more difficult to implement quickly.

Smaller firms often have a different set of circumstances.

Decision-making may be concentrated among a few partners or senior professionals. Workflows may be easier to evaluate. Changes can sometimes be tested and implemented without coordinating across multiple departments or offices.

And in the current environment, I think that flexibility could be valuable.

A smaller firm that understands its valuation processes and is willing to evaluate new technology seriously may be able to move from experimentation to practical implementation relatively quickly.

That doesn’t mean moving carelessly.

Professional oversight, data security, reliability, and quality control remain essential regardless of firm size.

But there is a difference between being appropriately cautious and allowing existing processes to prevent meaningful change.

I think firms that understand that distinction may have an opportunity to establish capabilities before larger competitors implement them at scale.

Buying AI Tools Isn’t the Same as Changing the Operating Model

One thing I’ve emphasized in conversations about AI is that simply adding technology to an existing process has its limitations.

Most firms can identify opportunities to automate individual tasks.

Maybe AI can help draft a report section, summarize financial information, identify anomalies, or check calculations.

Those improvements are useful.

But if the underlying engagement process remains essentially unchanged, there’s a limit to how much the firm can benefit.

The larger opportunity is to reconsider how the work should be performed.

For example, if AI can generate a financial model, should the engagement still be organized around the same sequence of manual construction and review?

Or should we reconsider the process so that professionals spend more time evaluating assumptions, testing outputs, and documenting conclusions?

If a system can identify potential normalization adjustments, should an analyst continue performing every preliminary calculation manually?

Or should the workflow focus on reviewing those proposed adjustments, determining which are appropriate, and documenting the reasoning?

Those are operational questions.

And I think they’re more important than simply identifying which AI model performs best on a particular task.

For smaller firms, this creates an interesting opportunity.

They may be able to redesign their workflows around emerging capabilities without having to preserve as much existing organizational infrastructure.

But that advantage only exists if they’re willing to reconsider the process itself.

A small firm that simply purchases the same tools as everyone else isn’t necessarily going to become more competitive.

The advantage comes from understanding how to incorporate those capabilities into the actual work.

The Competitive Window May Be Temporary

There’s an important qualification to all of this.

I don’t think smaller firms should assume they’ll maintain an advantage simply because they can move faster today.

Large firms still have significant strengths.

They have established relationships with major clients, recognized professional brands, extensive distribution, specialized expertise, and the resources to develop sophisticated internal systems.

Once those organizations integrate AI more fully into their valuation operations, they may be able to combine their existing market position with substantially improved execution efficiency.

That’s a powerful combination.

And it could place considerable pressure on smaller competitors.

Consider what happens if a large firm can produce certain types of valuation work much more efficiently while maintaining its existing client relationships and professional reputation.

The traditional cost advantage of a smaller firm may become less meaningful.

At the same time, the larger firm may be able to offer faster delivery, more standardized processes, and broader analytical capabilities.

That’s why I think the timing matters.

There may be a period when smaller and mid-sized firms can implement meaningful changes before larger organizations complete their own operational transitions.

But I wouldn’t count on that period lasting indefinitely.

And I wouldn’t assume that simply adopting AI earlier guarantees a lasting competitive advantage.

The more important question is whether firms use the opportunity to develop better processes, stronger capabilities, and an operating model that can continue improving as the technology advances.

The Advantage May Come From Understanding the Work

There’s a tendency to think that the firms with the largest technology budgets will ultimately have the strongest AI capabilities.

And financial resources certainly matter.

But I think there’s another factor that may be just as important.

How well does the firm understand its own work?

For years, valuation professionals have developed detailed processes for collecting information, performing analyses, constructing models, reviewing assumptions, and preparing reports.

Much of that knowledge exists in the experience of individual professionals, internal templates, review procedures, and established working practices.

Some firms have documented those processes extensively.

Others rely more heavily on the knowledge and experience of the people performing the work.

As AI systems become more capable, I think that distinction may become increasingly important.

A firm that understands its processes in detail is in a better position to determine which activities can be performed by technology, where professional intervention is necessary, and how results should be reviewed and validated.

It can also identify opportunities to eliminate steps that may no longer be necessary.

A firm that hasn’t documented or evaluated its processes may find implementation more difficult, regardless of how sophisticated the technology becomes.

In that sense, the competitive advantage may not come from having access to a particular AI model.

Many firms will have access to similar underlying capabilities.

The advantage may come from how effectively those capabilities are incorporated into the firm’s operating model.

And that’s an area where a smaller, well-organized firm could potentially compete very effectively.

A Different Way to Think About Growth

I think one of the most significant implications is how valuation firms may approach growth in the future.

Historically, the question has often been how many additional professionals a firm needs to support a certain volume of work.

That question won’t disappear.

There will always be a need for qualified professionals who can evaluate complex circumstances, exercise judgment, interact with clients, and take responsibility for valuation conclusions.

But the relationship between headcount and production capacity may become less direct.

Firms may increasingly look at how to expand capacity through better systems, repeatable processes, and carefully designed workflows before adding people.

That could change hiring decisions, investment priorities, pricing strategies, and even the types of engagements firms choose to pursue.

It could also create opportunities for highly specialized boutique practices that combine deep professional expertise with sophisticated technology.

A smaller firm may not need to compete with a large organization across every dimension.

It may be able to concentrate on particular industries, valuation applications, or client needs while using technology to support the execution of that work.

I think that’s an interesting possibility.

But again, it requires looking at AI as more than a way to reduce the time spent on existing tasks.

It requires thinking about what kind of firm you’re trying to build.

What Should Valuation Firm Leaders Be Thinking About Now?

I don’t think there’s a single operating model that every valuation firm should adopt.

Different firms serve different clients, perform different types of engagements, and operate under different constraints.

But I do think there are some questions worth considering.

How dependent is our current capacity on adding professional headcount?

How well have we documented the processes that drive our valuation work?

Which parts of those processes could be performed differently with emerging AI capabilities?

What would our firm look like if we redesigned its operations around those capabilities?

And perhaps most importantly, are we evaluating these questions now, or are we waiting to see what our competitors do?

I think that last question matters.

For years, technology has helped valuation professionals work more efficiently.

But we’re now beginning to see capabilities that could change how firms are structured, how they grow, and how they compete.

Smaller firms may have an opportunity to respond to those changes more quickly than larger organizations.

That doesn’t guarantee success.

And it doesn’t eliminate the advantages that larger firms have spent decades building.

But it does create a potentially important opening for firms that are willing to rethink how they operate.

Historically, building a larger valuation practice meant building a larger team.

Increasingly, it may mean building better systems around a highly capable team.

The question for smaller valuation firms is whether they’ll use that opportunity to change how they compete—or wait until larger competitors have done it first.

Better valuation operations begin with better questions.

Explore how ValueVision is building specialized agents, connected operating infrastructure, and practical advisory services for the future of valuation.